Hutch's posterous

Hutch's posterous

Hutch Carpenter  //  VP of Product for Spigit (http://spigit.com). Father of two young 'uns who misses running marathons. San Francisco, CA. I blog regularly about innovation and social software at I'm Not Actually a Geek

May 9 / 9:41am

Customer Suggestions: When to Listen, When to Ignore >> Pragmatic Marketing #innovation

Ignore customer suggestions

Sometimes the best way to satisfy a customer’s need is to ignore their suggestions. “Customers have ideas about incremental improvements to their workflow, but if we develop something that is truly innovative, our ideas probably won’t make sense to existing customers.1 Sometimes when we solve a market problem, our solution may completely eliminate existing workflows, activities, and tasks with a better process. In many cases, customers only know their way of doing things while we have a broader perspective across many customers’ processes and a deeper understanding of technology capabilities. An individual customer does not have our aggregated view of the larger market problem across multiple customers and a deep understanding of technology.

Listening to our customers’ suggestions may lead to incremental improvement instead of real innovative market solutions but ignoring them all together can produce even worse consequences! It is by going out and observing our customers using our solution that we see how they interact with our products in their environment. There are many things people never verbally communicate because they are unconsciously doing them or they do not see them as important. For example, they may have created special information “cheat sheets” they need to do their job. I have observed numerous customers’ end-users who have a spreadsheet on their network to manage information that could be incorporated into the product and completely change the way they accomplish activities. Most customers do not have the deep understanding of technology capabilities. And, from their perspective, we are, quite frankly, one of many vendors to them— just a part of their overall process—and they think of our products and solutions in this context.

You need to have a sense of where your own product should go, and leverage that in considering customer suggestions. The danger is in completely ignoring customers, myopically assuming you know more than they do about what they want. It's a case-by-case approach.